The NIL Influencer Formula

Why NIL Is Really About Influencer Marketing

When people hear "NIL," most immediately think of endorsements. And when they think of endorsements, they picture the biggest names - the quarterback on national TV, the All-American gymnast with a million TikTok followers.

But that’s only part of the picture.

The most common way student-athletes are earning NIL income today is social media. According to our NIL Research Poll, over 85% of all NIL transactions involve some form of influencer-style activation: posting on Instagram, sharing a product in Stories, creating content for TikTok, or even tagging a brand in a game-day post.

NIL is influencer marketing.

And if you’re a brand looking to partner with student-athletes - or a coach or administrator trying to help them - you need to understand how influencer selection really works.

Successful Brands Start with Their Goals

The biggest mistake I see brands make in NIL? Picking the athlete first and the objective second.

Smart brands don’t just look for reach or star power. They start with questions:

  • Are we trying to reach a specific group (e.g. high school athletes, college students, young women in sports)?

  • Is the goal to drive traffic to our site? Sales? Email sign-ups?

  • Do we want to associate our brand with values like hard work, community, or leadership?

Once a brand knows what they’re trying to achieve, then they go looking for the right partner - someone who can make that happen through authentic content.

NIL isn’t about who has the biggest follower count. It’s about who’s the best fit.

What Brands Actually Look for in a Student-Athlete Influencer

Here’s what brands are looking at:

Demographics
What’s the athlete’s age, gender, and school location? Does that align with the brand’s target audience?

Content Style
Is the athlete funny? Inspirational? Educational? Are they posting behind-the-scenes content, lifestyle moments, or wellness tips? Does their content feel consistent with the brand’s tone?

Platform Presence
Where are they most active?

  • Instagram is the top NIL platform, especially for lifestyle brands.

  • TikTok is great for reaching a younger audience.

  • YouTube is king for long-form storytelling, but harder to grow.

  • Twitter/X is less valuable.

Engagement, Not Just Followers
10,000 followers with 500 likes per post outperforms 50,000 followers with 100 likes per post. Engagement is a better predictor of influence than reach.

Audience Alignment
Brands aren’t paying to reach everyone. They’re paying to reach the right ones.

Influencer Tiers

Brands don’t just sort by “fame.” They think in tiers.

Here’s a quick breakdown brands often use, adapted to the NIL context:

Nano Influencer (1K–10K followers)

Pros:

  • Extremely high engagement

  • Strong niche loyalty

  • Very affordable for brands

Cons:

  • Limited reach

  • Often newer to content creation

Micro Influencer (10K–50K followers)


Pros:

  • Strong influence within their niche

  • Great value and cost-effective

  • Semi-professional content production

Cons:

  • Still growing audience

  • May lack polish or experience

Mid-Tier Influencer (50K–100K followers)
Pros:

  • Broader audience reach

  • Professional-quality content

  • Loyal follower base

Cons:

  • Higher costs

  • Engagement may decline as audience grows

Macro Influencer (100K–1M+ followers)
Pros:

  • Mass exposure and large-scale visibility

  • Strong brand recognition

  • High production value

Cons:

  • Expensive

  • Feels less personal or authentic

  • Lower engagement rates compared to smaller tiers

What Brands Avoid: Red Flags in Influencers

Here’s what can make even a talented, charismatic athlete an instant “no” for brand deals:

  • Inconsistent Posting: If the athlete hasn’t posted in the past month, brands assume their audience isn’t engaged.

  • Low-Quality Content: Dark, grainy, or sloppy posts signal a lack of professionalism.

  • Fake Engagement: Bot comments, purchased followers, or inflated likes can be spotted a mile away by savvy marketers.

  • Over-saturation: If 7 out of 10 posts are sponsored, that athlete’s credibility is probably declining. Brands want partnerships, not just ads.

  • Content Misalignment: It’s common sense. If a wellness brand sees an athlete’s feed filled with sugary soft-drink content, they’ll walk away.

  • Poor Communication: Slow replies, missing deadlines, or vague deliverables can ruin deals quickly.

Athletes don’t need to be perfect. But they do need to be prepared.

What Coaches and Admins Can Do to Help Athletes Succeed

You don’t need to be a social media expert to help your athletes navigate NIL. But you do need to understand what matters.

Help Athletes Build a Personal Brand
This doesn’t mean picking a logo or tagline. It means helping them understand: What do I want to be known for?

The best NIL-earning athletes have a clear identity that goes beyond sport.

Encourage Smart, Consistent Posting
Encourage regular posting - pre-game content, workouts, leadership moments.

Offer Practical NIL Education
Workshops, online courses, or 1-on-1 coaching can teach athletes how to:

  • Reach out to brands professionally

  • Read basic contracts

  • Price themselves appropriately

  • Disclose partnerships properly

Most brands expect student-athletes to be new to this. They just want to know the basics are covered.

What Brands Should Remember About Student-Athletes

Working with student-athletes is different from working with full-time influencers.

They’re students first. They have practice, travel, and academic commitments. They’re still learning to manage their voice and their time.

But that’s also what makes them powerful.

Athletes have built-in credibility, discipline, and community presence. They’re followed by future recruits, classmates, alumni, and local fans. When they speak, people listen.

And when they speak authentically, it works.

The Real Magic: Finding the Overlap

The best NIL partnerships happen when three things align:

  • The brand knows what it wants to achieve

  • The athlete knows who they are and what they stand for

  • The school supports the athlete in building that foundation

If you’re a brand, your best NIL partner might not be the biggest star on campus.
If you’re a coach, your best recruiting advantage might be teaching your athletes how to show up online.

And if you’re a student-athlete? Remember this: You don’t need a million followers. You need to know your story—and be willing to share it.

About Bill Carter

Bill has advised brands on Name, Image, Likeness for 25 years—first in pro sports, now at the college level. He was the Co-Founder of the Gen Z sports agency Fuse, which he sold in 2019. In 2020, he founded Student-Athlete Insights and consults on NIL strategy with Fortune 500 companies and 30+ DI universities. Read more about Student-Athlete Insights.

Bill Carter