NIL Reality Check

The hype surrounding NIL has created a misleading impression that every student-athlete is poised for success. Here are the 5 most common factors that contribute to disappointment and unrealistic expectations:

#1 Unequal Marketability

It's crucial to address the elephant in the room: NIL opportunities are not distributed equally across all student-athletes. The hype surrounding NIL often paints a picture of universal success, but the reality is more nuanced. Marketability, a complex blend of factors, plays a pivotal role in determining which athletes attract brand interest.

Sport and Position: Certain sports inherently draw more attention and NIL dollars whether from brands or Collectives. Football and basketball athletes, particularly those in high-profile positions like quarterback and point guard, tend to have a larger market appeal. Athletes in sports with less of a fan base or who play less high-profile positions find it challenging to garner the same level of NIL interest.

Skill Level: Exceptional talent naturally attracts more attention. Star players with impressive statistics and accolades are more likely to catch the eye of brands seeking to associate with excellence (not to mention the desire of Collectives to retain those athletes at their schools.) Non-elite student-athletes face greater difficulty securing deals.

Social Media Presence: Social media clout is a valuable currency. Athletes with large, engaged followings can leverage their platforms to promote brands and products, making them more attractive to potential sponsors. While student-athletes with under 10,000 followers (nano-influencers) can still find NIL success, it can be a struggle.

The Disparity Gap: This disparity in marketability can create a sense of disillusionment for athletes who don't fit the "ideal" mold. It's essential for student-athletes to understand that NIL success isn't guaranteed for everyone. Managing expectations and focusing on personal development within their sport can lead to more fulfilling experiences, regardless of their marketability level.

#2 Overestimation of Earning Potential

Media outlets tend to focus on the most sensational and lucrative NIL deals, showcasing athletes signing six-figure contracts and partnering with major brands. These stories, while captivating, create a distorted perception of NIL's financial landscape. The reality is that the majority of deals are much smaller, often involving local businesses or social media promotions.

The Highlight Reel Effect: It's easy for student-athletes to fall into the trap of comparing themselves to the outliers, leading to unrealistic expectations about their own earning potential. This can create a sense of disappointment when the reality doesn't match the hype.

The Importance of Perspective: It's crucial for student-athletes to remember that NIL is not a get-rich-quick scheme. Most athletes will not become overnight millionaires through endorsement deals. Instead, NIL should be viewed as an opportunity for personal branding, networking, and financial literacy development.

Setting Realistic Goals: By setting realistic goals and understanding that their NIL journey will likely involve a series of smaller, incremental steps, student-athletes can avoid the pitfalls of overestimation and focus on sustainable growth.

Education and Guidance: Educators and mentors play a critical role in helping student-athletes navigate the complexities of NIL. By providing accurate information about the financial realities of NIL and emphasizing the importance of long-term goals, we can empower athletes to make informed decisions and set realistic expectations.

#3 Time Commitment & Pressure

While NIL success is enticing, it's important to acknowledge the significant time commitment and pressure that come with pursuing and managing NIL opportunities. The demands of attending classes, training, competing, and maintaining a social life are already substantial for student-athletes. Adding NIL to the mix can create an overwhelming burden.

The Juggling Act: Athletes must carve out additional time for activities such as negotiating contracts, fulfilling brand obligations, creating social media content, and attending promotional events. This balancing act can lead to sleep deprivation, increased stress, and a decline in academic performance.

The Pressure to Perform: NIL deals often come with performance-based expectations. Athletes might feel immense pressure to excel in their sport to maintain their marketability and attract future opportunities. This pressure can negatively impact their mental health and overall well-being.

Burnout and Disillusionment: The cumulative effect of these factors can lead to burnout, disillusionment, and a loss of passion for both sport and NIL.

Prioritizing Well-being: It's crucial for student-athletes to prioritize their mental and physical well-being. Setting boundaries, learning to say no to certain opportunities, and seeking support from coaches, mentors, and mental health professionals are essential for navigating the challenges of NIL.

Education and Advocacy: NIL educators and athletic departments have a responsibility to educate student-athletes about the time commitment and pressure associated with NIL. Providing resources for time management, stress management, and mental health support can help athletes thrive in this new landscape.

Read the rest of this newsletter about the need for an NIL Reality Check: 5 Myths That Set Student-Athletes Up for Disappointment.

It’s now just $5 per month. Paid subscribers get 4 NIL/edu newsletters per month, immediate free access to the leading digital course - NIL/mba course (usually $150), and the archive of the Top 50+ most popular newsletters since 2020.

#4 Comparison & Social Media

Social media has revolutionized the way student-athletes connect with fans and brands. However, it has also created a hyper-visible environment where NIL deals are constantly on display. This exposure can lead to a toxic culture of comparison, fueling feelings of inadequacy and unrealistic expectations.

The Illusion of Perfection: Social media often presents a curated version of reality, highlighting only the most glamorous aspects of NIL deals. Athletes might see their peers posing with luxury cars, signing autographs at exclusive events, or vacationing in exotic locations, all thanks to their NIL success. This can create a distorted perception of what is normal or achievable.

The Comparison Trap: As athletes scroll through their feeds, they might start to question their own worth and wonder why they haven't achieved the same level of success. This comparison trap can trigger negative emotions like envy, jealousy, and self-doubt, leading to a decline in mental well-being and a loss of motivation.

The Unseen Struggles: It's important to remember that social media rarely showcases the hard work, setbacks, and rejections that are part of every athlete's NIL journey. The focus on highlights can obscure the reality that most athletes face challenges and experience failures along the way.

Promoting Healthy Perspectives: NIL educators, coaches, and mentors have a crucial role to play in helping student-athletes develop healthy perspectives on social media. Encouraging them to focus on their own goals, celebrate their own achievements, and avoid comparing themselves to others is essential for maintaining a positive mindset.

Fostering Authentic Connections: Social media can also be a powerful tool for connecting with other athletes and building a supportive community. By sharing their own struggles and celebrating their successes, athletes can create a more authentic and empowering online environment.

#5 Unforeseen Challenges & Risks

The excitement surrounding NIL can overshadow the potential risks and challenges that athletes may encounter. These unforeseen complexities can lead to setbacks, disappointment, and even legal trouble if not handled properly.

Financial Pitfalls: While NIL offers the promise of financial gain, it also introduces athletes to a new world of taxes, financial management, and potential scams. Without proper guidance, athletes might mismanage their earnings, fall victim to fraudulent schemes, or make unwise investments or decisions that could negatively impact their financial aid.

Legal Complexities: NIL deals involve contracts, intellectual property rights, and compliance with NCAA and state regulations. Navigating these legal intricacies can be overwhelming for young athletes who lack experience in these matters. Missteps can result in disputes, contract breaches, or eligibility issues.

Education and Preparation: NIL education is paramount in equipping athletes with the knowledge and skills necessary to navigate these challenges. Workshops, on-demand courses, and mentorship programs can provide valuable insights into financial literacy, contract negotiation, and legal rights.

Seeking Professional Guidance: Athletes should be encouraged to seek professional guidance from financial advisors, attorneys, and agents who specialize in NIL. These experts can help them make informed decisions, protect their interests, and avoid potential pitfalls.

Building a Support Network: A strong support network of coaches, mentors, and family members can also play a crucial role in helping athletes navigate the complexities of NIL. These individuals can offer guidance, advice, and emotional support throughout the process.

By proactively addressing the potential risks and challenges associated with NIL, we can empower student-athletes to make sound decisions, protect themselves from exploitation, and maximize the benefits of this new era of college athletics.

About Bill Carter

Bill has advised brands on Name, Image, Likeness for 25 years—first in pro sports, now at the college level. He was the Co-Founder of the Gen Z sports agency Fuse, which he sold in 2019. In 2020, he founded Student-Athlete Insights and consults on NIL strategy with Fortune 500 companies and 30+ DI universities. Read more about Student-Athlete Insights.